Cities Outlook 2023
Why struggling cities still lead their regionsWhile many cities perform poorly against the national average, they still play an important role in their regions despite this underperformance.
Home to many hundreds of thousands of jobs, Leeds plays a central role in Yorkshire's economy. But just how reliant are high streets in the city's surrounding towns on its success?
Two main factors drive the success of a place’s high street: the strength of the economy in that place and the strength of other places within commutable distance.
Take Leeds. Home to many hundreds of thousands of jobs, Leeds accounts for around 36 per cent of all economic output in its wider area. In particular, it is a centre of high-knowledge production, benefiting not just residents in the city but also those living around it.
Recent ONS data indicates the wages of workers in Leeds were higher than the wages of its residents. This tells us that higher-paid jobs in Leeds were disproportionately being done by people who lived outside of the city.
Source: ONS
Data shows:
Combining this data with the findings from Figure 1 suggests that the stronger the commuting links with Leeds, the more prosperous a surrounding town is. Without access to outside job opportunities, places with smaller local economies of their own and more retail-dominated town centres might find themselves in a more precarious position. However, the access to higher-skilled, higher-paid jobs Leeds offers puts money in commuters’ pockets, playing a central role in driving local consumption and helping high streets in the city’s surrounding towns thrive.
In brief, a strong Leeds benefits the wider area and policy should be supporting its continued success as a centre of the knowledge economy.
While many cities perform poorly against the national average, they still play an important role in their regions despite this underperformance.
The recent focus on struggling high streets ignores the success of well-performing city centres and misdiagnoses the real problem: a lack of high-skill jobs
Central government and metro mayors must work together to harness innovation in northern cities and boost their economies.
Writing for the Yorkshire Post, Andrew Carter argues that Channel 4's final decision to move it’s HQ to Leeds is a testament to the many advantages the city offers, and, by succeeding, Leeds reaffirms itself as an economic force for the UK.