People have returned to city centre shops and bars as lockdown has eased. But they haven’t responded to calls to go back to city centre offices.
Last weekend the Prime Minister made his second call for office workers to return to their desks in a bid to support the struggling high streets of the UK’s largest city centres. What’s curious is that while people have responded to the easing of lockdown of leisure amenities, the PM’s requests for people to return to their city centre workplaces appear to be falling on deaf ears.
The chart below shows the change in footfall in the UK’s 63 largest city centres after a series of policy announcements. Footfall in the two weeks following the opening of non-essential shops (in June) and pubs and restaurants (4th July) saw an increase after each announcement from Monday through to Sunday. And the Eat Out to Help Out scheme saw footfall pivot, with a boost to Mondays to Wednesdays. Meanwhile there was no strong drop off later in the week – although weekends were very slightly down – suggesting that people did not simply shift their nights (or days) out.
Source: Locomizer
But there was no such response to the Prime Minister’s first request in July for workers to return to the office, especially in large city centres. In central London and Manchester, early August weekday footfall rose by just one percentage point compared to early July. Leeds, Bristol and Nottingham all saw no change. And in Birmingham city centre the number of workers fell.
Last weekend Boris Johnson tried again, this time in a slightly more barbed way. Looking at the sluggish recovery in footfall in large city centres it’s clear to see why the PM is so keen to get workers back to the office. The ability of these centres to pull workers in from far and wide was a boon for their high streets. But they are now hamstrung by the reluctance of workers to return, with implications for the shops, cafes and restaurants that had built their businesses on their custom.
Our High Streets Recovery Tracker, sponsored by Nationwide, will soon show whether there is a response to this second request. But with many companies already telling staff they aren’t expected to return until the end of the year, the Government may need to extend support to the high street services in our largest city centres if there are to be any amenities for these workers to return to.
While the take-up of the Job Retention Scheme has increased everywhere in January to reflect the third lockdown, there are signs that things are less bad than during the first one.
We’re due to fill out our census forms in less than four weeks’ time, but the roadmap for lifting Covid-19 restrictions should trigger a delay.
Our latest briefing shows that the Core Cities' city centres have been particularly affected by Covid-19. Policies aimed to kickstart an economic recovery should focus on getting centres working again, in terms of public transport and air quality, commercial property, and investment in skills.
The Covid-19 recession is very different to previous ones, and its recovery is likely to be so too. We should expect the UK economy, and many of its cities, to experience a sharp bounce back.
Leave a comment
Be the first to add a comment.